It's a big night for Wingston and Barktholomew, two dads excited to see their daughter Baella return from college, just in time for a nice, vegan Halloween dinner. But their best laid plans are thrown to the winds by the appearance of an unexpected guest - for their daughter has decided to bring along her new girlfriend, a young lady from a well-to-do witching family, with the refined tastes to match a girl of her station!
Now, with the moon quickly rising and the cauldron bubbling over, Wingston and Barktholomew will have to pull off the best dinner they can to impress this mystery girl. Tensions run high, anxieties even higher, but should it all fall apart, how will this family come back together?